Share this:

OCC Resolution:

Addressing Local Labour Market Needs through the Ontario Immigrant Nominee Program

Submitted by Thunder Bay Chamber of Commerce, Co-Sponsored by Greater Sudbury Chamber of Commerce, Timmins Chamber of Commerce, North Bay & District Chamber of Commerce 

At the 2019 Annual General Meeting of the Ontario Chamber of Commerce, the Thunder Bay Chamber of Commerce presented the following resolution:


Employers across Ontario, but particularly in small cities of under 200,000 population and rural areas, are experiencing a shortage of qualified employees and a shrinking labour market.  This challenge will continue to grow as existing workers retire. 


Many employers are already facing a shortage of qualified employees and communities are struggling with a shrinking labour market.   According to research by the Ontario Chamber of Commerce, finding someone with proper qualifications is the top challenge for businesses looking to recruit new staff.1  

One part of the solution to the skills shortage challenge is through progressive immigration policies and processes.   The current Ontario Immigrant Nominee Program (OINP) is one area where Ontario’s policies put us at a disadvantage in attracting migrants to meet our labour market needs.  The list of eligible professions is narrow and does not include many of the professions that are experiencing shortages such as plumbers, chefs, personal support workers, and truck drivers.   

To add further challenges, the OINP requires employers to obtain a labour market impact assessment (LMIA) prior to offering a job to a recent migrant.  This LMIA uses provincial information in determining whether a job can be offered to an immigrant.  Employers in small and rural communities who are unable to attract Canadian citizens from major urban centres are often denied the opportunity to hire an immigrant because the LMIA data shows that sufficient Canadian citizens are available to fill the role but does not consider whether Canadian citizens are willing to relocate to that area.   

A third area of concern is that the OINP does not allocate any of its 6,600 nominated spots to support regional immigration.  Between 2011 and 2016 more than three-quarters of all immigrants to Ontario (both Federal & OINP) arrived in the Greater Toronto Area.  The OINP would be best utilized by supporting the attraction efforts of communities outside of the GTA. 

The Manitoba Immigrant Nomination Program demonstrates the efficacy of being flexible. It includes a much broader list of eligible professions, does not require a LMIA, and provides local communities the opportunity to nominate a certain number of migrants to address local labour shortages.  This approach has seen positive results.  Each year, some 15,000 immigrants arrive in Manitoba.  According to provincial data, 90 percent of Manitoba nominees are employed within their first year and over 130,000 Provincial Nominees have landed since 1998 with a 90 percent retention rate. 

The expansion of the list of in-demand jobs to include NOC skill level C, the elimination of the need for a labour market impact assessment for small and rural communities, and the allocation of a percentage of nominee spots by region would improve the ability of small and rural communities to address labour shortages through the OINP. 


The Ontario Chamber of Commerce urges the Government of Ontario to: 

  1. Implement changes to the Ontario Immigrant Nominee Program by:
    1. expanding the list of eligible professions to include NOC skill level C positions that are in demand in each community; 
    2. allocating OINP spots on a regional basis to address labour market needs; and 
    3. working with the Federal Government to eliminate the requirement for a labour market impact assessment for OINP participants to be hired in Ontario communities with populations under 200,000. 

This is a Provincial Issue.
Our local Members of Provincial Parliament:

Thunder Bay – Atikokan
Judith Monteith-Farrell

Thunder Bay – Superior North
Michael Gravelle, MPP

The Thunder Bay Chamber of Commerce' advocacy work is made possible thanks to the generous support of our

Cornerstone Members:


All News:

Issues & Insights: November 2019

On November 6, the Government of Ontario released its 2019 Fall Economic Statement entitled, “2019 Ontario Economic Outlook and Fiscal Review: A Plan to Build Ontario Together,” which provides an update on the government’s finances and announces commitments for the upcoming 2020 Budget…

read more

Good News October 2019

Our Members are amazing! This month’s Good News includes items from Breakfast, Lunch & Deener, OLG and Resolute Forest Products!

read more

Letter of Support: Indigenous Youth Supportive Housing Project

We are proud to count the Thunder Bay Indigenous Friendship Centre among our valued Members and to express our support for the Indigenous youth supportive housing initiative that the organization is leading in partnership with Métis Nation of Ontario, Ontario Aboriginal Housing Services, and the Ontario Native Women’s Association…

read more

Upcoming Chamber Events

Nominations for 2020 Business Awards – presented by Bell
Online – takes 3 minutes! Nominations close @5pm December 13th.
YQT: November 2019
Synergy North Board Room
Lunch & Learn with Wake the Giant
Prince Arthur Waterfront Hotel

More events >>


Share this: