Ensuring Provincial procurement policies provide best value to regional communities

A letter to Hons. Peter Bethlenfalvy and Greg Rickford

April 16, 2019

Honourable Peter Bethlenfalvy
President of the Treasury Board
Via email: Peter.Bethlenfalvy@Ontario.ca / Karl.Baldauf@ontario.ca

Honourable Greg Rickford
Minister of Energy, Northern Development and Mines, and Indigenous Affairs
Via email: Greg.Rickford@ontario.ca / Nina.Chiarelli@ontario.ca


Dear Honourable Ministers:

Ensuring Provincial procurement policies provide best value to regional communities.

In order to directly engage the Provincial Government on policy issues of interest to our region, the Chambers of Commerce in Sudbury, Timmins, Sault Ste. Marie, North Bay and Thunder Bay wish to highlight our concerns around the Provincial Government’s recent announcement of a major initiative to consolidate and centralize procurement spending within Ontario Public Service and broader public sector agencies.

Alternative Financing and Procurement (AFP), or public-private partnerships, are a highly viable option for risk sharing on major infrastructure projects and should remain a priority across Ontario. However, concerns expressed about the impacts to local small- and medium-sized businesses as a result of a centralized purchasing model are of significant concern to Northern communities.

We are advocating against a centralized Greater Toronto Area (GTA) model as we believe that regionalized procurement efforts can deliver similar cost savings, while retaining, and controlling public spending within a region. We strongly believe that a GTA based buying model puts Northern businesses at a disadvantage and impedes the ability to build capacity throughout the province. To provide a regional example, the Lakehead Purchasing Consortium in Thunder Bay has a local award track-record in the 90 percent range, successfully demonstrating support for regional businesses while attaining cost savings through spend consolidation.

Recently, as part of the Ontario Chamber of Commerce’s Advocacy Day at Queen’s Park, we raised these concerns regarding a centralized procurement model with the Deputy Minister for Energy, Northern Development and Mines, Bill Thornton.

As Northern Ontario is an integral part of the provincial economy, we trust you will consider mutual policy goals in a way that best serves all Ontarians. We would welcome the opportunity to discuss this issue with you, either individually or collectively, at your earliest convenience.


Keitha Robson, Chief Administrative Officer, Timmins Chamber of Commerce.
Email: krobson@timminschamber.on.ca

Debbi Nicholson, President & CEO, Greater Sudbury Chamber of Commerce
Email: debbi@sudburychamber.ca

Rory Ring, CEO, Sault Ste Marie Chamber of Commerce
Email: rory@ssmcoc.com

Peter Chirico, President & CEO, North Bay & District Chamber of Commerce
Email: peter@nbdcc.ca

Charla Robinson, President, Thunder Bay Chamber of Commerce
Email: charla@

Cc Bill Thornton – Deputy Minister, Northern Development and Mines – bill.thornton@ontario.ca
Gilles Bisson – MPP Timmins – GBisson@ndp.on.ca
Jamie West – MPP Sudbury – JWest-QP@ndp.on.ca
France Gélinas – MPP Nickel Belt – fgelinas-qp@ndp.on.ca
Ross Romano – MPP Sault Ste. Marie- ross.romano@pc.ola.org
Vic Fedeli – MPP Nipissing- vic.fedeli@pc.ola.org
Michael Gravelle – MPP Thunder Bay – Superior North – mgravelle.mpp.co@liberal.ola.org
Judith Monteith-Farrell – MPP Thunder Bay-Atikokan – JMonteith-Farrell-CO@ndp.on.ca

The Thunder Bay Chamber of Commerce' advocacy work is made possible thanks to the generous support of our

Cornerstone Members:


All News:

Experience Learning: Skilled Trades

Skilled Trades Dylan DeRosa, a former TBCDSB high school student explored a co-op placement with Aqua North Plumbing and Heating that has since grown into a full-time apprenticeship to become a skilled tradesperson. Chris Massaro, Aqua North Plumbing and Heating...

read more

Upcoming Chamber Events

More events >>